Actually, the bumper sticker popular around my hometown was “God said it, I believe it, and that settles it.”
Even as a girl, I thought this was a little sad. What if your interpretation of what God said turns out to be wrong? What if God said precisely the opposite of what you thought? Then what? Do you scrape off the bumper sticker, or do you edit it in some way, maybe make it “I thought God said it and I did believe it, but now I’m pretty sure I was wrong.”
I’ve just said no thank you to a nice man who is still a member of my church and e-mailed me to ask me to explain “Dating Jesus.” He’s offered to buy the book as a study guide for how I’ve wandered from my old theology. To show his bonafides, I think, he let me know he’s taught Sunday school and filled in as an elder and a deacon at church, so I let him know that I’ve taught Sunday school (and bus ministries), too, but given my gender, the church wouldn’t allow me to build my spiritual resume to be as impressive as his.
My brother once said that a fundamentalist’s style of arguing goes thus: We hit ‘em hard, we hit ‘em fast, and then we leave ‘em to bleed out on the floor. I know the theology of my church — intimately — and, speaking as a trained fundamentalist, I know how fruitless it is to try to enage someone like me in an argument. Not to brag, but we make fabulous lawyers. We take our literalist and legalistic minds and we chew through debate.
The man asked if I was a wall (a closed mind) or a jar of clay (willing to change). I told him that I’m betting my immortal soul that God never intended a separate and unequal world for the genders.
Does that make me a wall?
He responded that he’s known plenty of women who have grown up to be writers and teachers of other women within the church. So if I would be happy talking to women, surely I can come on home. But that church is not my home. It stopped being my home years ago, when the questions I kept asking about girls and women and boys and men could not be answered.
I emphatically did not write “Dating Jesus” to encourage people to leave their church. If you’re happy where you’ve landed, rock on. But if you’re sitting in a pew with your hands balled into fists, or if you’re not sitting in a pew because you’re just too angry to even try, then try to think of that discomfort as your still small voice telling you your theology is out there.
So here is my prayer: When we die, we go to heaven and find that God is a big African American lesbian covered in tattoos and piercings who opens her wide arms and says, “Come on in, darlin’.” I can’t speak for the gentleman with whom I corresponded, but I know there are certain members of my tribe who will take one look, and then they’ll turn around and march straight to hell, so fearful they are of thinking of the holy as feminine.
Bless their hearts. I think I just unsold a book.
Getty Images