Don’t judge Islam on its haters:

I’ve said this before, but now I’ve said it again on my day job.

What I didn’t say, was this: Three days after the terrorist attacks on 9/11/01, I and a photographer friend named Al went to New York with the army of journalists who descended on that city to try to figure out what happened. Based on Al’s research, we ended up at a Brooklyn firehouse, where the neighborhood was busy throwing its arms around its own Squad 1, an elite firehouse that answered the call that Tuesday morning for a 1060 — a major calamity.

I am the wife of a firefighter. I live with the idea that one day, Mr. DJ may not come home, but I trust his judgment, his training, and his smarts that if there’s a way out of a calamity, he will find it.

But how does one prepare for a building folding up like an accordion, killing thousands in an instant? I, like everyone else, watched that happen on television, my hand over my mouth, on some level not believing it really happened until I saw it for myself.

It really happened. As Al and I went over the bridge at daybreak, the stinking mess was still smoking.

It was also emitting a noxious cloud that killed would take more lives, though more slowly than the original casualties.

We stayed at Squad 1 for two days while the neighbors waited to hear the awful news that they’d lost all 12 firefighters. I watched people form an endless casserole brigade. I witnessed solemn hugs, and I saw this: a little girl in a tutu drop a wadded-up $5 into a donations jar (for the families of the 12 who were over at what firefighters were then calling “The Show.” “Ground Zero” would come later), and then, she threw her stick-thin arms around the legs of a firefighter on duty, a beautiful Black Irish man who could only look down at her, and nod stiffly.

I swore I’d not walk up to any one and ask questions and I didn’t. I didn’t have to. Life unfolded in front of me, I stood there, quiet in the corner in awe at the raw and open heart of America beating strong. I don’t think I’ve ever been so moved. Even now, typing this, I can work up tears. We’d been slammed to the mat, and there we were, busily brushing one another off, asking “What can I do? Are you OK?”

Al and I came back to Hartford, Al to share his heart-wrenching photos, me to write a story. The package ran in the paper and then sank like a stone into the sea of tales churning out of the day.

But it changed me profoundly in more ways than I can count even now, nine years later.

I’d just come off of six years at Hartford Seminary. I had spent time in classes with Muslims, talked with them, eaten with them, read their sacred text. When that big, beating heart started constricting, I could not be a part of that.

And then, about six months after Brooklyn, a friend suggested my cough that wouldn’t go away might be something serious. I dragged myself to a doctor (I’m not a fan of doctor visits), who sent me to a pulmonologist, who found that I’d developed moderate-to-severe asthma. I got inhalers, pills, shots, the whole nine yards, and I learned not to let colds go too long.

As my pulmonologist tried to find the reason for my asthma, he began exploring the fumes I’d breathed in in New York. Evidently, there in Brooklyn, where the air smelled like burned flesh and gunpowder, and there in Manhattan, when I went to see how close I could get to the wreckage, I breathed in agents that seared my airways.

Don’t feel sorry for me. I don’t feel sorry for myself. The effects of my asthma have dissipated over time, and I rarely have a moment when I can’t catch my breath. Anyway, it was worth it. As a respected colleague said: It was an honor to be a witness.

About that pulmonologist: He’s a Muslim, and we began chatting during my office visits. I feel sorry for whoever was scheduled after me, because I took up as much of his time as possible. To say he was a caring man doesn’t begin to describe him. To say he was patient with my stupid questions doesn’t, either.

I learned a great deal from my doctor, and not just about the workings of my lungs. And yes, I know how this sounds. By all means, strike up the kazoos for a round of “Kumbayah,” but as I was honored to cover 9/11 up close, I am honored to be a patient of this particular doctor, to read his sacred texts, and to stop a moment before I hate, take a deep breath (sometimes courtesy of Advair), and to listen.

48 Responses to Don’t judge Islam on its haters:

  1. A beautiful story, as if we would expect anything less. Don’t you feel sometimes that all the elements of your life come down to this one moment, that you have a unique perspective on this story, that no one else could tell it in quite the same way?

  2. Nice piece in The Courant today. You have some interesting “fans” over there.

    • They don’t appear to recognize my genius, do they?

      • They do seem pretty single minded. “I don’t hate all Muslims, I just don’t want *this* mosque *here*.”

        They claim to be empathetic with the victims of 9/11 and their families, but when it comes time to chose a Supreme Court justice, “empathy” is a dirty word.

        A little consistency here, folks! A little consistency, please!

      • I’ve been trying to discover how you incorporated your secret agenda of abortion and gay marriage into the piece, but I’m not having much luck. But I’ll keep studying on it.
        It’s in there somewhere.
        Maybe if I read it backwards……

    • What leftover said.
      I would bet my life on Jesus voting that the Westboro group is NOT practicing the kind of Christianity he taught. Come on lightning, strike me dead if I am wrong about that. What Jesus do they follow? I love it that you say straight out what this group does, without really condemning (you leave that up to the reader). You speak of goodness and ask fair questions, then mention their (hate-filled) responses. You are really fair, kind, but brutally honest in your reporting. It’s ironic that the account of what is actually done angers the very people who support them. I mean, if they turn on you, that means to me that they see how bad it looks. All they can come up with is a personal attack on you. The slimes!

      BTW – No lightning. I’m still here.

  3. If journalism is dying, you’ve played no part in killing it.

    I think we oftentimes get lost in our “unique perspective” without really realizing that we live in world of billions of unique perspectives. The days and weeks after 9/11/2001 sort of reminded us that we are all in this together – billions of unique perspectives melded together. We could be one.

    “There is a land of the living and a land of the dead and the bridge is love, the only survival, the only meaning.” – Thornton Wilder

    But in the years since, so much of that sentiment has morphed into plain old jingoism. Us vs them, with “us” being strictly defined.

    But I take comfort in knowing there are other people in the world who haven’t lost that the sense that sometimes a catastrophic event can unite. And “the Bridge is love.”

    I bet Mr. DJ is reminded of this just about every day.

    • Thank you. We take such comfort in us v. them, don’t we? It just feels righteous. It’s so much harder to open a fist once it’s closed.

      And I am a lucky woman to know Mr. DJ but if you told him I said that, I will deny it.

      • We needed to find the enemy after 9/11 and I guess when that became too tough, some settled for “looks like the enemy”. Sad.

        • That sounds about right. We are more comfortable fighting against an enemy than our individual wars within.

          I sound like a fortune cookie.

          • Ha! Speaking of fortune cookies, I found a fortune that I had saved as I was sorting through papers earlier. It’s in my pocket now. Let me pull it out. It says: “Love is as necessary to human beings as food and shelter.” Some days, stories like the one above are like my breakfast – a little story of love.

      • I neglected to mention the other day when I cited my career path that I submitted an application to the New Haven Fire Department some time back in 1990 or something. But by the time they got back to me I was already well-entrenched in my musical journey.

        Fittingly, or maybe ironically, from early 1994 to late 1996 I lived right next door to West Battalion HQ in New Haven. On many occasions we’d be lugging amps and gear up to the third floor at two or three in the morning, looking forward to going to bed, when we’d see them heading off to call somewhere; thinking to ourselves, man that is more “rock n’ roll” than rock n’ roll.

  4. Beautiful, DJ. Your words allow me to experience so much more of life than what’s possible from just living my own. And, you help me think and imagine a world beyond what I could possibly do on my own. Thank you for that gift.

  5. Thank you, that’s all just thank you.

  6. DJ, ignore the idiots who just don’t get it.
    “Do not give what is holy to dogs, and do not throw pearls before swine, lest they trample them under their feet, and turn and tear you to pieces.” (Matthew 7:6).
    Thus endeth the lesson.

  7. Tell that other person that she better not duel with DJ bloggers we are fierce and loyal!

    • A mighty fortress is our God, a bulwark never failing . . .

    • I’d hate to be on the other end of an argument with this crowd, actually. It’s like having a very cool posse. We don’t all agree, but don’t pick on us. Or else.

  8. DJ, poignant and brilliant.

  9. “We don’t all agree, but don’t pick on us. Or else.”
    Yup. reminds of the days when I believed I could tease or pinch my little sister because she was, well, MY little sister. But I did beat up a kid in the neighborhood who tried the same thing!

  10. From your Courant story: “using “church” and “Christian” to describe these [Westboro Baptist] haters feels like gargling gravel”

    The Force of Metaphors is strong with this one! (Is there a Yoda of Journalism?)

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s